Grab your hot cocoa and bundle up by the fire.
We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process. Mantels
Tired of streaming Netflix’s “Fireplace for Your Home” when guests come over? It might be time for you to invest in a sleek electric fireplace that you install right into your wall.
Not only does this type of fireplace come smoke- and hassle-free (that’s right, no need to gather wood!), but it's safer to operate, according to Good Housekeeping Institute Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab Director Dan DiClerico. But what we love most about electric fireplace inserts is that they’re an easy way to add warmth to any room of your home, and unlike space heaters, they’re a cozy, stylish addition to your space. Below, we list our favorite electric fireplace inserts, including everything from the most affordable to the most luxurious picks.
The engineers and product analysts at the Good Housekeeping Institute test everything you need to create the perfect home, from air purifiers and whole house humidifiers to the best TVs that go right above your fireplace. When narrowing down the best electric fireplace inserts, our engineers evaluated each pick’s ease of installation and use, design, number of settings and safety. According to our pros, these are the best electric fireplace inserts that your friends and family will love bundling up next to this winter, based on our Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab’s extensive testing data, familiarity with top-performing brands and positive consumer reviews.
After our top picks, continue reading to learn more about how electric fireplace inserts work and why you can trust our recommendations.
Available in a variety of sizes from 28 to 100 inches and designed to be mounted into a recessed wall, this electric fireplace insert is the perfect choice for most homes seeking a cozy atmosphere. Not only will the fire look realistic, but our pros love that it comes with a log set and crystals, which can be swapped out at any time to suit your style. Just keep in mind that it can be difficult to remove the glass pane and make the actual swap, according to Rachel Rothman, executive technical director at the Good Housekeeping Institute.
In testing, we found this model easy to operate and appreciated the choice among three flame colors and five intensities. According to our pros, the heat ranges from 68°F to 88°F and the unit will shut off automatically if it ever heats past 88°F. We also like that you can make adjustments via an included remote or directly on the fireplace itself. And as a bonus, it's compatible with Google Assistant and Alexa so you don't even have to move from the couch to turn on the heat.
Featuring over 1,000 reviews on Amazon and an average 4.6-star rating, this electric fireplace insert can be popped into your old fireplace; just plug it in and you're all set. While we haven't yet tested it in the Lab, our pros love that it looks like a proper fire pit and that you can choose among five levels of brightness. While it may not be as sleek as some of our other picks, we appreciate that a remote comes included and that you can operate the flame with or without heat. "This fireplace insert looks like a live fire burning and keeps the room warm even in freezing weather," one online reviewer says.
Simple and elegant, this premium electric fireplace will be the centerpiece of your home. It's available in three sizes and suited for a recessed 10-inch space or a pre-built fireplace, though you can purchase it with a DIY trim kit to help solidify the look if your existing fireplace is slightly larger than the insert.
According to Modern Flames, it can heat a room up to 400 square feet and reach temperatures up to 88°F. While it's expensive, what our pros love most is that you can choose among 10 unique color variations and adjust the room's ambiance in a snap. We also appreciate that the insert features built-in touch controls in addition to a remote.
Designed to be used in a pre-existing fireplace, this insert is as close as it gets to the real thing. Though it's on the pricey side, there's no need to hardwire it into your home as it can be plugged into any standard household outlet. Even cooler is that you can fill up a reservoir within the fireplace with water to give it a misting effect that imitates smoke, thanks to Opti-myst technology.
"This is meant to provide the look of an actual fireplace, without the smoke and fumes that can adversely affect a home's indoor air quality," says Dan DiClerico, the Good Housekeeping Institute's Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab director. A full reservoir is claimed to last around 14 to 17 hours before refill, but you can skip the "smoke" effect if it's not for you.
It would be difficult to find a more realistic-looking electrical fireplace than this one, which comes with its own mantle but nicely fits into your pre-existing fireplace or recessed wall. Once installed, you can choose among five flame effects and adjustable brightness settings, alternating between a crackling fire or a gentle flame depending on your mood.
Also unique is that this fireplace uses infrared technology for heating instead of fan convention, meaning that it should heat the room faster than a traditional heater. Our pros like that you can adjust settings on the control panel or with the provided remote, and a timer makes it possible to leave the insert on while drifting off to sleep (knowing that it will turn off after a set amount of time). Plus, according to ClassicFlame, this insert features Safer Sensor Technology that automatically shuts off the heater if it overheats to prevent electrical or product issues.
However, our engineers do point out that this fireplace likely heats a much smaller area than the claimed 1,000 square feet and advise always double-checking how many BTUs per square foot are typical before purchasing anything.
As a log-set style insert, this pick from Dimplex is made to be installed in a recessed area. It plugs into a standard outlet, so you can either install it in an outlet in the back of the fireplace to hide the cord or just snake it along the wall.
Visually, our pros think it looks similar to a traditional fireplace. There's no housing around it, which is part of what makes it easy to install and aesthetically appealing. We like its simple design, but keep in mind that you cannot swap out any mediums and there's only one size available online so make sure to measure your space first.
According to the brand, this insert should be able to effectively heat up a standard-sized room up to 400 square feet. A remote is included for convenience, and lights and effects work independently of the heat so you can use your fireplace in the summertime without worrying about your home getting too hot.
All you need is an outlet to get your fire started with this simple plug-and-play insert. This model can be both recessed into the wall or directly wall-mounted, allowing you to place it wherever you want in the house, although sizing is limited. It's also worth noting that this set comes with logs and two fillers (crystal and stone), which you place at the bottom of the fireplace to customize to the look you love.
With multiple flame and color settings and even a color-changing mode, you can easily switch up the ambiance to suit the vibe of the night. Best of all, if you want your fireplace on in the middle of the summer, just turn off the heat and enjoy its LED flames. But if it is a chilly night, Real Flame claims that the fireplace goes up to a whopping 99°F. It also has an auto-shutoff safety feature, according to the brand, to prevent overheating.
You don't need an existing fireplace to install this pick, which comes equipped with a wall bracket so you can mount it to the wall. Several online reviewers relay how easy it was to install.
Once assembled, it should heat a 400 square-foot space, according to the brand, and it'll keep guests entertained with 12 color modes that let you choose the flame and flame bed shade you like best. On top of that, you can adjust the fire's brightness and speed among five settings. "It looks great and the different color options are really cool," one online reviewer says.
While a remote is included, we like the touchscreen controls on the unit, which are easy to use and responsive. And according to R.W.Flame, it's built with a safety feature that turns the device off if it ever overheats.
One of the most versatile electric fireplace inserts on this list, this model can be installed anywhere you want, from a pre-built fireplace to a TV console, or leave it freestanding as is. Our experts love that you can adjust the shade of your fire to one of three flame colors, and there are five flame brightnesses to match the mood you want to create.
You can control the insert by using the control panel's buttons or the included wireless remote. If you don't want the fireplace running for more than eight hours, make sure to set up the timer. According to the brand, the heat goes up to 82°F and it features an overheat function if it gets too hot. One pro tip: Pay attention to the measurements of this unit. While the size is listed as 28.5 inches, that refers to the width, not the height. From top to bottom of the floor, it is actually 21 inches.
Constructed to be recessed in the walls, this fireplace insert comes with a log set, crystals and driftwood so you can change the medium that the fire comes from to a style that suits your living room decor. According to our pros, it's extremely easy to remove the front glass plate to make any swaps. It comes with a high price tag, but this insert has 60 different color combinations to choose from, as well as the ability to adjust the flame's speed for even more customization.
"This is one of the more high-tech inserts we tested," Rothman says. "It's Alexa- and WiFi-enabled, so you can use your phone to control the insert as well." If you don't want to use the app, it comes with a remote control. On cold evenings, you can set the thermostat up to 88°F, but what our pros appreciate most is that even at high temperatures the insert remains safe to touch.
The engineers and product analysts at the Good Housekeeping Institute have evaluated at least a dozen electric fireplace inserts in the past three years.
To choose the best ones for your home, we first evaluate whether they’re easy to set up and install. Next, we consider whether the fireplace mediums (i.e. logs or crystals) are changeable and, if so, how easy it is to change them out for other pieces. If the electric fireplace insert is compatible with an app, we evaluate how easy it is to connect to and navigate. We also consider the number of customizable settings, including flame color, speed or intensity and brightness.
Lastly, we verify safety claims by using a thermal gun to confirm what temperature the fireplace reaches when on to determine whether it’s safe to touch, especially around pets and kids.
✔️ Installation type: Inserts can either be hard-wired or plugged in; confirm which option you're buying before purchasing. You'll also want to consider your existing set-up. While inserts are meant to be placed inside built-in fireplaces, not every home has one. To solve this, you can always create a hole in your wall to fit the insert inside. Or if you'd rather skip the trouble, opt for an electric fireplace insert that can be wall-mounted or placed inside a TV stand.
Installation note: If you install an electric fireplace insert into a pre-built fireplace, you must make sure it is properly sealed from the chimney. If not, rainwater, dirt or debris could get inside and damage the machine.
✔️ Heating type: There are two ways the insert can heat your home. Keep in mind that electric fireplaces are meant to be cool to the touch, but they do produce heat to warm the room. Though most units will let you use the fireplace function without creating heat, it's best to supervise pets or children while in use.
Some homes or condos aren't built with fireplaces, but that doesn't mean you can't have one. If you've decided that you love the cozy, modern look and feel of a fireplace, consider an electric fireplace insert that you install inside an existing fireplace or, if your home wasn't built with one, directly inside your wall.
Because electric fireplaces don't actually burn wood like traditional fireplaces would, you don't need a venting system that removes smoke from your home. In fact, electric fireplace inserts don't produce anything beyond heat, making them similar to other electric heaters you may own. "The great thing about electric inserts is they don't need to exhaust outside, the way wood-burning and vented gas fireplaces do," says DiClerico. "It's a clean, convenient alternative." What is the downside of an electric fireplace? You'll have to create a depression in your wall if one is not already there. If this worries you, consider an electric fireplace insert that's wall-mountable or that can be placed inside a TV cabinet. Although this technically won't be an "insert" and the look won't be quite as sleek, it's another great option.
GH Institute Test Engineer Alec Scherma has experience testing many household products and working on different types of machinery. As a mechanical engineer by trade, he brings years worth of knowledge and information when it comes to testing and installing home products.
This guide was most recently updated by writer and product analyst Olivia Lipski, who covers everything from consumer electronics to home, outdoor, fitness and more. She consulted the Good Housekeeping Institute’s Home Improvement and Outdoor Lab director, Dan DiClerico, as well as the Lab’s extensive testing data, to include the latest top-performing picks.
Alec Scherma (he/him) is the Good Housekeeping Institute’s test engineer, where he helps to create and implement new product testing methodology across home, cooking and cleaning appliances, wellness, tech products and more. He graduated from Drexel University’s College of Engineering with a B.A. in mechanical engineering.
Olivia (she/her) is a media and tech product reviews analyst at the Good Housekeeping Institute, covering tech, home, auto, health and more. She has more than five years of experience writing about tech trends and innovation and, prior to joining GH in 2021, was a writer for Android Central, Lifewire and other media outlets. Olivia is a graduate of George Washington University, with a bachelor's degree in journalism, political science and French, and she holds a master’s degree in communications from Sciences Po Paris.
The Best Shoes for Nurses
The Best Vegan Meal Delivery Services
The Best Prepared Meal Delivery Services
The Best Meal Delivery Services
The Best Weight Loss Meal Delivery Services
Our Kid Testers Loved These 45 Board Games
Stroll On: The Best Gifts for Walkers
A Part of Hearst Digital Media
Good Housekeeping participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites.
Built In Electric Fireplace ©2024 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.